|
. |
UN, Ukraine see low Chernobyl toll, environmentalists protest VIENNA (AFP) Sep 06, 2005 Belarus, Russia and Ukraine joined UN experts Tuesday in saying fears of radiation effects from the Chernobyl nuclear accident nearly two decades ago were exaggerated. However, environmentalists protested that the experts' estimated eventual death toll of up to 4,000 people was much too low. Kalman Mizsei, from the United Nations Development Program (UNDP), told the UN-sponsored Chernobyl Forum that met in Vienna Tuesday: "For the vast majority of people, the fears associated with exposure to radiation from Chernobyl have been exaggerated. "The damage, both to human health and natural environment, has been much smaller than commonly assumed," he said. "People in the affected communities can, with very few exceptions, pursue normal lives," Mizsei told the forum, which brings together experts from eight UN agencies, as well as the governments of the main affected countries Belarus, Russia and Ukraine. A report by the forum said that the total number of people expected to die over time from cancers from the disaster was likely to be at most 4,000 out of some 600,000 people who were subjected to radiation in the most affected regions, far lower than other predictions of tens of thousands. It also said there had been only 56 deaths so far -- 47 rescue workers who received whole-body high doses of radiation and nine children who had died from thyroid cancer. The forum's conclusions are "ridiculous," Greenpeace environmental group researcher William Peden told AFP. "It is way too early to make such bold assertions when so many questions remain unanswered and many thousands more may die in decades to come," Peden said. Oleksiy Pasyuk, of the Ukraine National Ecology Center, said in Kiev: "We are worried that they are suggesting allowing people to once again live in the affected areas... Their goal is to push for development of nuclear energy." In Belarus, physicist Georgi Lepnin, who himself received massive doses of radiation as a rescue worker at Chernobyl, said: "The figure of 4,000 dead is a huge under-estimate." He said that some 10,000 of the 200,000 rescue workers, the so-called liquidators, had died even if authorities tried to pass this off by saying they had perished from heart attacks and other non-cancer causes. Other ecologists said that many more than 600,000 people were affected. But US radiation expert Fred Mettler explained that people who got lower doses than those in this group were at no higher risk from cancer than anyone in the general population. "After all, the whole northern hemisphere can be said to have been affected by contamination from Chernobyl," Mettler said. The explosion on April 26, 1986, of the number four reactor at the Chernobyl power plant in what was then the Soviet republic of Ukraine sent a radioactive cloud across Europe in what was the worst nuclear accident in history. Burton Bennett, who chaired the meeting, said the 4,000 figure should be taken as a sign of the extent to which authorities have "overplayed the health consequences" of the accident. He said misinformation was responsible for a range of psychological problems as people in the region of Chernobyl thought they were doomed to get cancer, when in fact their exposure to radiation had been relatively low. Mohamed ElBaradei, head of the UN's watchdog atomic agency, said in a speech read out to the opening session that "poverty, mental health problems and 'lifestyle' diseases have come to pose a far greater threat to affected communities than radiation exposure." Mizsei said an "industry has been built on this unfortunate event," with 22 percent of the 1991 national budget of neighbouring Belarus being dedicated to Chernobyl relief, a figure that has since dropped to six percent. Russian Nadezda Gerasimova said "that the most grave results of the Chernobyl accident were in the social area rather than in the radiological area" and that the time had come to cut down on some benefits to people, although many resisted this. All rights reserved. � 2005 Agence France-Presse. Sections of the information displayed on this page (dispatches, photographs, logos) are protected by intellectual property rights owned by Agence France-Presse. As a consequence, you may not copy, reproduce, modify, transmit, publish, display or in any way commercially exploit any of the content of this section without the prior written consent of Agence France-Presse.
|
. |
|