. Military Space News .
Spy Sat Lessons Part Four

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by Martin Sieff
Washington (UPI) Nov 23, 2007
Some of the greatest innovative designers in aerospace history like Barnes Wallis and Sidney Camm, father of the P. 1154 Harrier STOVL in Britain, and the legendary Clarence Kelly, father of the entire Lockheed Martin "Skunk Works" in the United States, performed some of their best and most visionary work at advanced ages.

Other countries venerate age and experience in industrial management far more than major U.S. corporations do -- most strikingly Japan, which remains the most successful industry-exporting nation in the world with a record of quality control in its exports -- including those produced at its companies' U.S. plants with 100 percent American workforces.

It is also striking that among the many areas where U.S. corporations like Boeing and Lockheed Martin continue to perform superbly is on programs they have been operating for decades, or where they have been steadily maintaining and upgrading technologies on systems, using workforces and managements that have been allowed to pass on their accumulated experience and expertise to their successors.

Boeing's superlative, world-beating airliners, through the 777 and the Dreamliner, are clear, evolutionary successors and developments on the basic design of the Boeing B-47 Stratojet that made its first flight in December 1947. Even before the B-47, Boeing had led the world in pioneering high altitude, fast, pressurized cabin strategic bombers with its B-20 Superfortress through World War II. Thus, one of America's most important commanding leads in profitable, export-oriented advanced technology in the 21st century is based on a line of accumulated, retained engineering, development and design stretching back more than 60 years.

Similarly, Lockheed's expertise in developing high altitude and satellite surveillance systems also predates the Space Age. It was also producing Clarence Kelly's U-2 at the Skunk Works in the 1950s.

Lawyers, politicians and accountants on Capitol Hill and in successive administrations have an inherent tendency to rate the slick, plausible proposals that companies eager to move in on each other's territory submit to them on bottom one figures only. If a company claims to be able to make an ambitious system far more cheaply than competitors who have been making similar systems for decades, it will be rated on the bottom line it projects. None of the assessors or their political masters is likely to risk embarrassment or accusations of bias by competitors with far less experience and expertise who put in lower bids.

The political echelon in both parties -- after all, it was the Clinton administration, not the second Bush one, that made the disastrous decisions that led to the $4 billion FIA fiasco -- has arguably less firsthand acquaintance with engineers and scientists and the issues they deal with than any previous ruling class in the United States at least since the Civil War.

None of them ever stop to ask whether a program can be carried out by a company, whether the manpower and technological resources necessary to fulfill it are avoidable, or what kind of financial and resource reserves will be available to cope with development problems and delays. None of them factors the Second Law of Thermodynamics or Murphy's Law into their cost assessments. But those eternal truths are always there, the ghosts in the machine, ready to do their worst.

Advanced technology is not magic -- it cannot simply be willed to work, automatically and glitch free, always on time, without a huge amount of time, sweat, experience and learning mistakes factored into the equation. Until U.S. policymakers learn those basic lessons, they will continue to produce fiascoes like the FIA program.

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Military Space News at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Defense Focus: Spy sat lessons -- Part 3
Washington (UPI) Nov 20, 2007
Why is the U.S. defense industry sector having such difficulty with producing so many ambitious programs like the Littoral Combat Ship, the Space-Based Infrared System, and the Future Image Architecture program on budget and within reasonable time, compared with its triumphs of a generation ago? One major reason is that early triumphant programs were created by an earlier generation.







  • Russia studying US missile defence proposals: agencies
  • Analysis: EU deals with Russia weaken bloc
  • India, China to break ice with first-ever wargames
  • Putin warns NATO against border build-up

  • Outside View: Russia's nuclear plans
  • Bush plays down WWIII warning
  • Ahmadinejad rules out Iran nuclear concessions
  • Outside View: Iran nuclear divisions

  • India tests SAM missile near Pakistan border: officials
  • Asymmetrical Iskander Missile Systems
  • Raytheon Delivers 3000th Joint Standoff Weapon To The US Navy
  • Raytheon Standard Missile-3 Achieves Dual Intercepts In Space

  • Russia dismisses US offers on missile defence: reports
  • US 'listens' to Russian concern on missile defence: Putin
  • BMD Watch: Poles may put BMD base on hold
  • BMD Focus: Euro-base blues -- Part 2

  • China to order up to 150 Airbus jets during Sarkozy visit: report
  • Time Magazine Recognizes The X-48B
  • Virgin to offer carbon offsets alongside drinks and perfume
  • NASA sorry over air safety uproar

  • BAE Systems Wins Unique Approval For Unmanned Air Systems
  • Elbit Systems To Supply UAV Systems To The Israeli Defense Forces
  • Unmanned Air System Project For South Coast Formally Launched
  • SDS Awarded Contract By USAF To Enhance MQ-1 Predator Training System

  • Ex-US commander in Iraq backs troop pullout bill
  • Feature: Marines build ties in Anbar
  • US commander gives part credit to Syria for military gains in Iraq
  • Iran agrees new talks with US on Iraq

  • First Bomb Drop Of The New RAF Typhoon
  • Analysis: China eyes new Russian tech
  • LockMart Announces Alcoa As Principal Team Member To Compete For Joint Light Tactical Vehicle Program
  • Thompson Files: Sell F-22 to Japan

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement