Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Military Space News .




WAR REPORT
Why America needs boots on the ground in Iraq
by Arnaud De Borchgrave, Upi Editor At Large
Washington DC (UPI) Oct 01, 2014


We cannot bomb IS into obscurity: US military
Washington (AFP) Sept 30, 2014 - The US military cannot bomb the Islamic State group into "obscurity," it cautioned Tuesday, appealing for patience in its escalating attempts to defeat the jihadists in Syria and Iraq.

"No one said this would be easy or quick, and no one should be lulled into a false sense of security by accurate air strikes," Pentagon spokesman Rear Admiral John Kirby told reporters.

"We will not, we cannot bomb them into obscurity."

Kirby spoke a week after Washington launched air raids against the IS group in Syria, with dozens of bombing runs flown by American and Arab aircraft.

The raids have struck IS-controlled oil refineries, tanks, artillery, buildings and other targets, even as the militants continued to gain ground in some areas, including near a contested town near the Turkish border where Kurdish forces have been pushed back.

Kirby criticized some media coverage as raising unrealistic expectations about the air campaign in Syria and Iraq.

Commanders from the outset had made clear that air power alone would not be enough while a long-term effort would be needed to train and arm Syrian rebel forces and strengthen Iraq's army, he said.

"Even as we share the sense of urgency about this group, we must also share a sense of strategic patience about this entire effort. And I think some of that has been lacking," Kirby said.

IS fighters are no longer moving openly in large groups and are "dispersing" to avoid being hit from the air, he added.

But he acknowledged the group still posed a threat and in some cases had seized more territory -- even as it faces bombing from the air.

Effective air raids did not mean that "they aren't still trying and in some cases succeeding at taking and holding ground," Kirby said.

"We've been pretty honest about the fact that military action alone will not win this effort, but that shouldn't be taken as an admission of ineffectiveness.

"And one of the ways we know we're having an effect is precisely because the terrorists have had to change their tactics and their communications and their command and control," due to the air raids, he said.

US general says Syria rebel training could 'take years'
Washington (AFP) Oct 02, 2014 - Retired US general John Allen, who is leading the international effort against Islamic State extremists, said Wednesday that the training of Syrian rebels would be a slow process.

"It is going to take a while, it could take years, actually," Allen said in an interview with CNN. "We have to manage our expectations."

The US Congress has approved the training and equipping of moderate Syrian rebel units as part of an international plan to defeat the Islamic State (IS) organization in Iraq and Syria.

Allen said the training of Syrian rebels was already under way.

"The process of getting that unfolded is occurring right now with the idea of locating training camps and beginning to accumulate the Syrian elements that will go into those training camps," he said.

The United States, which leads the international coalition, initially launched strikes in Iraq on August 8 and widened its campaign on September 23 to include Syria, where IS has its headquarters.

Allen said the international response has provided an opportunity for new partnerships.

"It's actually an important moment where so many countries from so many different backgrounds share that view, that this is an opportunity to create partnership across those lines of effort that can achieve real effect," he said.

During the interview, Allen spoke about Iran's role in tackling IS fighters.

"We're not going to contemplate a bilateral coalition with Iran," he said, but went on to add that the Iranians "have a role to play, and where that role is helpful, we'll encourage it."

If President Obama's no-boots-on-the-ground in Iraq is his final word, they'll have to wear moccasins or some other comfortable footwear.

Bombing sans boots did not work in World War I, World War II and every other war from the Korean war to Vietnam to Iraq (I, II & III).

Bombing of North Vietnam without boots on the ground did not prevent a humiliating U.S. defeat.

And here the operative word is American. Iraqi boots have not prevented ISIS incursions 30 miles from Baghdad. Proper training of Iraqi commando units will take several more months.

There is an alternative to U.S. boots in Iraq to repel ISIS -- and that is Arab boots, e.g., Jordanian, Saudi and Egyptian combat footwear. But these Arab countries also have a significant part of their religious public opinion in clandestine sympathy with ISIS.

So these friendly Arab countries limit their military assistance to aerial bombing and strafing.

The U.S. can still opt out of bombs and boots and leave the fighting to others. But the final outcome could be an unmitigated disaster for the U.S. and its European allies as ISIS gathers sympathy and support throughout the Middle East.

A sine qua non for ending what otherwise is a war without end is the old adage that the enemy of my enemy is my ally, however briefly that may turn out to be the case in Syria.

The regime of Bashar al Assad is clearly the lesser of several evils.

But there appears to be a mindset about assisting Syria's anti-Assad, anti-ISIS fighters in the middle of the spectrum. This, for the time being, is in lieu of a more robust strategy.

Unfortunately, these pro-Western rebels are more interested in fighting the Assad regime than the far more lethal threat of ISIS.

Congress' House vote of 273 to 150 -- before taking two months off to campaign for November's elections -- showed deep misgivings in both parties about half measures' chances of success.

There is an uneasy feeling among both Democrats and Republicans that they voted for a stop-gap measure that was tantamount to wider military authorization that would follow the November elections.

The vote did nothing to advance the destruction of the Islamist state of ISIS. U.S. policies in Iraq since the 2003 invasion, based on deliberate lies about Saddam's Hussein's alleged nuclear arsenal, have been an abysmal failure.

The dismantling of Saddam Hussein's professional army was a tragic mistake. Highly professional Iraqi officers, dismissed by U.S. edicts, are now in the ranks of ISIS.

The new US-trained Iraqi army collapsed without a fight in northern Iraq, surrendering arms and equipment to ISIS.

Today, everyone seems to understand that a re-commitment to liberating Iraq from the forces of evil will take both treasure and time in a country that has proved time and again to be the graveyard of Washington's good intentions.

The U.S. is also laboring under a drastic cutback in defense expenditures ordained by the Administration and Congress.

Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-W.Va. said, "We have been at war in that part of the world for the past 13 years" and "if money and military might could have made a difference, it would have done so by now."

In lieu of boots on the ground, friendly Arab nations -- Saudi Arabia, UAE, Jordan, Bahrain -- joined the U.S. bombing campaign against ISIS targets with their fighter bombers.

Qatar, mentioned as one of the participants in the aerial campaign, provided access for refueling to Al Udeid near Doha, the largest U.S. air base outside the U.S. which is also forward HQ for the U.S. Central Command.

This is a delicate juggling act for Qatar as it maintains good relations with all manner of Islamist extremists. And it has invested some $200 billion abroad, from department stores in London to automobile companies in Germany to coast-to-coast real estate in the U.S. and mines in Latin America. Qataris also enjoy the highest per capita income in the world (over $100,000) with a native population of some 300,000 and a foreign labor force of over 2 million.

It will take the U.S. several more months to complete the training of new Iraqi army units, hoping this will fill the current porous battlefield gaps that ISIS uses with impunity.

Meanwhile, the U.S.-led air campaign is costly with no guarantee of success.

The options are re-engagement in Iraq with boots on the ground -- or disengagement and the spreading geopolitical malignancy of ISIS.

.


Related Links






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle




Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News





WAR REPORT
US-led strikes hit Syria's Raqa, Aleppo provinces: monitor
Beirut (AFP) Sept 29, 2014
Fresh US-led strikes hit Islamic State group targets in Syria overnight, both in its Raqa province stronghold and in Aleppo province further west, a monitoring group said on Monday. In Aleppo province, the strikes hit targets around the IS-held town of Minbej, including a complex of grain silos and a mill that the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said was being operated by civilians. ... read more


WAR REPORT
US plans Patriot missile sale to Saudi Arabia:Pentagon

Israel taps Raytheon for Iron Dome interceptor components

Raytheon producing backup components for missile defense radar

Raytheon providing ongoing support for Patriot air defense system

WAR REPORT
UAE asks U.S. for $900M rocket artillery deal

U.S. Navy eyes Norwegian missile

Raytheon announces full-rate production of Talon rocket

China shows off new missile test on primetime television

WAR REPORT
USMC Orders RQ-12 Wasp AE UAVs

AeroVironment's Wasp microdrone being supplied to Marine Corps

Fury glide bomb dropped from Shadow UAS

IBC Advanced Alloys Delivers First UAS Components for Analysis

WAR REPORT
'Space bubbles' may have aided enemy in fatal Afghan battle

Space control Airmen ensure constant communication

Russian Aerospace Defense Forces Again Dismiss Satellite Explosion Rumors

Harris Corporation supplying radios to Air Force Special Operations Command

WAR REPORT
Former Exelis business unit makes debut as independent company

UAE asks U.S. for $2.5B MRAP deal

Millog expands maintenance work for Finnish military

Seeing Through the Fog (and Dust and Snow) of War

WAR REPORT
German push onto world stage hit by defence failures

Poland, Pakistan, Lebanon seek U.S. military hardware

Airbus to restructure defence division, sell off units

Netherlands ups defence spending in wake of downed MH17

WAR REPORT
HK demos throw Beijing propaganda machine into overdrive

'CY' Leung: Hong Kong's embattled leader

Laureate says Nobel summit axed after Dalai Lama row

China detains activists for supporting Hong Kong protests: rights groups

WAR REPORT
World's smallest reference material is big plus for nanotechnology

Smallest possible diamonds form ultra-thin nanothreads

Engineers show light can play seesaw at the nanoscale

Nanoribbon film keeps glass ice-free




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement All images and articles appearing on Space Media Network have been edited or digitally altered in some way. Any requests to remove copyright material will be acted upon in a timely and appropriate manner. Any attempt to extort money from Space Media Network will be ignored and reported to Australian Law Enforcement Agencies as a potential case of financial fraud involving the use of a telephonic carriage device or postal service.