. Military Space News .
Afghanistan Decides Security

Afghan President Hamid Karzai (R) listens as British Prime Minister Tony Blair (L) addresses a joint press conference, at the Presidential Palace in Kabul, 20 November 2006. Photo courtesy of Farzana Wahidy and AFP.
by Stefan Nicola
UPI Germany Correspondent
Berlin (UPI) Nov 21, 2006
British Prime Minister Tony Blair says the world's security depends on success in Afghanistan, but Washington and others feel not all countries part of ISAF are doing as much as they could. The battle for Afghanistan has entered its bloodiest year yet. Some 180 coalition soldiers have died in 2006, most of them U.S., Canadian and British troops, many of them killed in the months since June when fighting with the Taliban escalated.

Neither the International Security Assistance Force nor the U.S.-led anti-terror operation Enduring Freedom has managed to contain the violence. On the contrary.

Apart from the volatile south, "several other regions are in danger of tipping as well," Citha Maass, a fellow at the German Institute of International and Security Affairs and one of Germany's leading Afghanistan experts, told United Press International.

The death toll of British troops stationed in the combat-heavy southern regions of the country since June stands at 36, a casualty rate higher than the one in Iraq. Despite domestic public pressure to bring home the troops, Blair said it was vital to defeat the resurging Taliban to secure global peace.

"Here in this extraordinary piece of desert is where the future of the world's security in the early 21st century is going to be played out," he told British troops in Afghanistan Monday. "We know that the only way to secure peace sometimes is to be prepared to fight for it."

Blair knows about the challenges. Together with the Canadians, the Dutch, the Australians and the Americans, British troops are taking some of the heaviest fire in southern Afghanistan.

"We will be with you in this endeavor," he continued. "Our commitment remains that whatever challenges, whether of security or reconstruction or development, we are up to meeting those challenges with you."

NATO-led ISAF has over 31,000 soldiers in the country; another 10,000 are fighting terrorism under Enduring Freedom.

But coordinating an ISAF mission from a pool of 37 different armed forces isn't easy; the caveats some of the domestic governments have imposed on their soldiers are a thorn in the eye of NATO officials.

"We need to better equip our forces in Afghanistan," NATO Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer said earlier this month. "That also means removing the restrictions some countries have put on their troops." Such a move would "send an important and necessary signal among the allies," he said.

The most prominent case is Germany. The country has nearly 3,000 soldiers stationed in the relatively peaceful northern provinces of Afghanistan, in Mazar-i-Sharif, Kunduz and Faizabad. Critics say the Germans are mere social workers in camouflage suits.

Pressure on Berlin to move some of its troops down south has increased in recent weeks, but the German government under Chancellor Angela Merkel has repeatedly stated the mandate, which keeps the Germans confined to the north, won't be changed.

The German unwillingness to give in to international pleas is a source of aggravation for officials from the casualty-ridden countries.

"You focus on rebuilding and peacekeeping, but the less pleasant activities you leave to us," a U.S. official recently told Karsten Voigt, the man in Berlin responsible for U.S.-German ties, the German news magazine Der Spiegel writes in its latest issue. He was later told that Germany needed "to learn how to kill."

Reports that 12 Canadian soldiers died because the Germans refused a request to help them in the south were quickly rebuffed by the Defense Ministry in Berlin, but both incidents point to the rising pressure on Germany.

While some say Berlin may not for much longer be able to refuse the international calls for help, other experts say the Germans are desperately needed in the north.

Many ethnic minorities populate these areas, and local conflicts could escalate any time, Maass told UPI.

The nitty-gritty work done by German soldiers in the north -- establishing contacts with the civic population and policing neighborhoods -- "doesn't look so spectacular in the press, but is equally necessary;" and thus, Berlin should keep its troops there, she said.

Maass faulted the U.S.-led mission Enduring Freedom, which was active in the southern provinces until ISAF took over this summer, with sparking much of the support for the Taliban there by arming tribal leaders and by bullying around civilians.

U.S.-led troops between 2002 and 2005 there repeatedly stormed the private compounds of Afghans, "kicking in doors of women's compounds," said Maass, who spent three years in Afghanistan to monitor elections.

"They behaved like bullish members of an occupying force," she said. "Over the years, that led to frustration and ultimately hate against the international forces in the southern provinces."

The international community is employing the wrong strategies, she said.

The province Helmand in the southwest, with many opium fields and warring tribal groups, will "surely" fall into the hands of the neo-Taliban if a plan to spray the poppy fields with chemicals to kill the plants is enacted, she cautioned.

"The international community needs to adapt a different strategy in the south, one that takes into account the many local tribal conflicts," Maass said. "ISAF needs to find discussion partners within the local communities" and combine military efforts with civic ones, such as educating teachers and local officials.

The window of opportunity for such an alternative strategy would last until the next Ramadan, Islam's fasting holy month, she said.

"If ISAF doesn't change anything, then the situation will continue to get worse and worse," Maass warned.

earlier related report
Afghans speed up army training
By Pamela Hess - UPI Pentagon Correspondent
Washington (UPI) Nov 21 - Afghanistan is accelerating the training of its 70,000-soldier strong national army by two years, Kabul's defense minister told Pentagon reporters Friday.

"We were supposed to have the figure of 70,000 somewhere by the end of 2010 and 2011. At the moment, I think we have expedited the process...and we want to have that figure sometime around October 2008... to reach the figure of 70,000," said Defense Minister Abdul Rahim Wardak. "We are thinking we'll be training 2,000 soldiers every month, and also add some more through direct accession."

Wardak said the Afghan defense ministry was working on improving the quality of the force as well as its size.

"We are redoubling our efforts to recruit and retain the soldiers and officers required, train them hard and ensure they uphold the high standard of professional conduct, and to eliminate corruption, poor leadership and misconduct," Wardak said.

"We are also taking steps to increase the retention rate of personnel who have completed their first three years of service," he said. "On behalf of the government of Afghanistan, I give a personal commitment that we will do our utmost to achieve these objectives."

The Afghan army is also looking for more and better body armor, air and ground mobility assets and firepower, as well as communications systems that are inter-operable with the United States and NATO forces.

"(We) need to have more fire power, to have more protracted mobility and to have air mobility, which is really most required in Afghanistan because of the mountainous terrain and also to be able to respond quickly to the emergencies," Wardak said.

U.S. Army Lt. Gen. Karl Eikenberry, the commander of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, said his command had developed proposals to fund those needs but would not specify the cost.

"Our government has not made the decisions yet as to what exactly, if any, of these set of proposals will be approved," Eikenberry said.

Whatever the cost, Eikenberry said it would be cheaper to outfit Afghan forces than have more U.S. forces there.

"When you look at the cost of our forces in Afghanistan versus the cost of Afghan forces, well, that's a much more expensive proposition for the United States of America," Eikenberry said.

The security situation in Afghanistan has deteriorated and the Afghan army and national police have an acute need for the equipment.

"The threat that the enemy poses in the battlefield right now is more significant than it was several years ago, so the Afghan National Army and the Afghan National Police, they need a higher level of protection, they need more mobility, they need better logistics systems, they need increased firepower," said Eikenberry.

"I think jointly, that now is a very appropriate time to increase the level of equipment, the sophistication of equipment, because that leadership exists now within the army, increasingly within the police, that they will be able to operate this equipment effectively, maintain this equipment over time," he said.

Eikenberry said some of the improvements were already being made: new body armor for the Afghan National Army and up-armored Humvees for elite commando battalions, as well as fixed-wing aircraft and helicopters, which are necessary to move troops in Afghanistan's mountainous terrain.

Wardak promised that if the Afghan army was properly equipped and trained, it would continue to fight alongside the United States in the war on terror.

"Once we are well-trained and well-equipped, we will be able to pay some of our debt to the international community by participating in peacekeeping operation or taking on the operation of shared interest and shared goals and to be also a permanent part of war against terrorism," Wardak said.

Source: United Press International

Related Links
International Security Assistance Force
News From Across The Stans

Pakistan's Musharraf Wants Meaningful Talks With Indian PM
Karachi (AFP) Nov 21, 2006
President Pervez Musharraf said Tuesday he is looking forward to "substantive" talks with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh when he visits Pakistan. Musharraf told reporters in this southern port city that the two countries need to resolve all outstanding disputes, including Kashmir, the reason for two of their three wars.







  • Fighting An Asymmetrical Chinese War Machine
  • Russia Prioritizes Strategic Forces On Security Agenda
  • Timetable For Climate Talks Implies US Could Be Out Of Kyoto Fold For Years
  • US Commander Meets Chinese Officials Ahead Of Military Drill

  • Macau Authority Denies North Korea-Linked Bank Accounts Unfrozen
  • Kim's Gift Politics In Challenge
  • IAEA Likely To Block Aid For Iran Nuclear Reactor
  • US Envoy In China For Talks On North Korea Nuclear Weapons

  • Cyber Summit Begins At Pentagon November 16
  • Northrop Grumman Expands Radar Role In Missile Testing
  • India Tests Nuclear-Capable Surface Missile
  • Pakistan Fires Nuclear-Capable Missile

  • Bush And Abe OK Faster BMD Cooperation
  • US, Japan Boost BMD Cooperation
  • USAF And Lockheed Martin Completes On-Orbit Checkout Of First SBIRS HEO Payload
  • The Democrat Approach To BMD

  • Aviation Industry Alarmed At New EU Emission Rules
  • Technologies Evaluated For The Future National Airspace System
  • Silent Aircraft Readies For Take-Off
  • Global Aviation Industry Gathers For Key Chinese Air Show

  • SkyLite B In Australia And New Zealand
  • EDO Wins Contract To Support Unmanned Aircraft
  • Boeing ScanEagle Achieves Major Flight Milestones
  • World's Operators Of The Northrop Grumman E-2 Hawkeye Gather For Annual Conference

  • Three Myths And One More In Iraq And Beyond
  • Worse Than Tet
  • US Military Plans To Boost Iraqi Forces With More Advisers
  • Gates To Follow Clark Clifford's Footsteps

  • The Mechanics Of Better Bullet Proofing
  • Israel Developing Bionic Arsenal
  • Air Force Declassifies Elite Aggressor Program
  • Raytheon Awarded $113 Million Contract For U-2 Systems Field Support

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement