. Military Space News .
Cruise Missile Sector Facing Supersonic Challenge

A JASSM being tested.
by Theodore Gaillard
Washington (UPI) Oct 11, 2007
Against Tomahawk-type cruise missiles, Russia's supersonic S-300PMU's kill ratio is listed as 0.8-0.98. The ad brochure claim may be excessively high, but a U.S. Government Accountability Office report highlighted a six-Tomahawk "stream raid" against the Rasheed airfield in which only two arrived over target after surviving far less sophisticated Iraqi defensive systems.

How ironic that more than 40 years ago the United States fielded the AGM-28B Hound Dog, an air-launched Mach 2 standoff cruise missile with 710-mile range, inertial/stellar navigation, mixed hi-lo dog-leg attack profile, and a one-megaton thermonuclear warhead.

Today? France's inertially guided ramjet-powered Mach 2-3 ASMP standoff cruise missile entered service in 1986 with a 300-kiloton nuclear warhead. Range: about 200 miles, similar to Lockheed Martin's Joint Air-to-Surface Standoff Missile, or JASSM.

But for pinpoint strikes in non-nuclear conflicts, current U.S. and EU conventional cruise missiles -- all subsonic -- would probably not survive advanced land- or ship-based defensive systems mentioned above.

What about other countries' comparable cruise missile capabilities? You judge:

China's ramjet-powered C-301 anti-ship cruise missile: Mach 2; 80-110-mile range -- depending on variant -- 1,130-pound warhead; inertial navigation with active radar terminal guidance; operational since about 1995.

China's Russian-built Sovremenny-class destroyers carry sea-skimming Mach 2.5 carrier-busting SS-N-22 Sunburn anti-ship ramjet cruise missiles. Range: 100 miles with 660-pound conventional or 200-kiloton nuclear warheads.

Mach 2.5-2.8 BrahMos ramjet anti-ship and land-attack cruise missiles -- a Russia-India joint venture -- now deployed with the Indian navy are about to enter service with India's army. They can be air-, ship-, sub-, or land-launched; 660-pound warhead; range: 80-200 miles, depending on altitude; preset inertial navigation with alternating inertial/active radar terminal guidance. Export discussions have reportedly occurred with Malaysia, Chile, South Africa, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates.

Russia? SS-N-12 Sandbox, conventional or nuclear, 300-plus mile range, Mach 2.5; SS-N-19 Shipwreck, conventional or nuclear, 300-plus mile range, Mach 2.5, deployed for decades on Russian carriers, cruisers and Oscar-class nuclear submarines.

Operational since 1984 and offered for sale to countries in addition to China, Russia's SS-N-22 Sunburn equips Sovremenny destroyers and various patrol boats. Guidance: initially inertial, with mid-course updates via aircraft or satellite; during terminal phase it employs a multi-channel seeker and 15G evasive 'S' maneuvers. Combat Fleets of the World describes it as a "very sophisticated weapon against which other navies have yet to develop an effective countermeasure," including the United States.

Indeed, in its entire cruise-missile inventory, the United States possesses no equivalents. Forget about replacing JASSMs with other subsonic missiles. Unless we develop and deploy our own stealthy, jam-proof, inertial/GPS-guided, terrain- and wave-hugging supersonic cruise missiles, technologically more advanced adversaries will control the battle space.

(Theodore Gaillard writes frequently on defense issues. His articles and book reviews have appeared in Jane's Defense Weekly, Defense News, the Washington Times and other newspapers and journals around the country. He is a consultant to the Center for Defense Information's Straus Military Reform Project.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Learn about missile defense at SpaceWar.com
All about missiles at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


NKorea tests new solid-fuel missile, MP says
Seoul (AFP) Oct 11, 2007
North Korea has successfully tested a highly mobile short-range missile which could hit targets inside South Korea with chemical or explosive warheads, a lawmaker said Thursday.







  • Sarkozy praises 'frank' talks with Putin, 'closer' views on Iran
  • Russian Parliament Postpones Consideration Of CFE Moratorium
  • Hu prepares to chart next five years for China
  • China's Hu: Cautious, efficient, and still a mystery

  • Analysis: DoJ's counter-proliferation push
  • No 'sudden moves' on Iran before IAEA report: Moscow
  • North Hails Nuclear Test As South Korea Demands Role In Disabling Process
  • Iran and IAEA discuss on nuclear questions

  • Cruise Missile Sector Facing Supersonic Challenge
  • NKorea tests new solid-fuel missile, MP says
  • Taiwan unveils missiles at National Day parade
  • Raytheon Awarded 150 Million Dollar Patriot Pure Fleet Contract

  • Russia Expects Positive US Response To Missile Shield Proposals
  • US proposes common missile defense network with Russia, NATO
  • Armavir Radar To Be On Combat Duty Late In 2007
  • BMD Watch: GBI hits ICBM in test success

  • MEPs seek limits on aircraft emissions by 2010
  • New Delft Material Concept For Aircraft Wings Could Save Billions
  • Aircraft And Automobiles Thrive In Hurricane-Force Winds At Lockheed Martin
  • Cathay Pacific chief hits out at anti-aviation critics

  • UAS Video Terminal Connects Boots On The Ground To Eyes In The Sky
  • Unmanned Aerial Vehicles Increase In Numbers
  • UAS Video Terminal Connects Boots On The Ground To Eyes In The Sky
  • Boeing Completes Eight-Hour Flight of A160T Hummingbird

  • Outside View: Mahdi Army threat in S. Iraq
  • How To Divide Iraq
  • Britain to cut Iraq troops to 2,500 by early 2008: PM
  • Double US air strike kills 25 in Iraq

  • Prospects of overseas deals boosting Israel Defense Industries
  • US to step up fight against illegal arms exports
  • Raytheon's 52 million Dollar F-15 AESA Radar Production Contract Gets Under Way
  • Lockheed Martin Installs First Arrowhead MTADS/PNVS Systems On Netherlands' AH-64D Apaches

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement