. Military Space News .
MILPLEX
'Entente frugale' is only choice for France, Britain: experts

British papers eye 'froggies' defence deal with horror
London (AFP) Nov 2, 2010 - British newspapers reacted with horror Tuesday to the country's new defence deal with historic rival France, evoking famous battles from 1066 onwards to question whether "the froggies" should be trusted. From the Battle of Hastings in 1066 -- a key victory on English soil which ushered in the first Norman king of England -- to the Battle of Waterloo in 1815, when British forces helped defeat Napoleon, Fleet Street plundered the history books to caution against the deal. British Prime Minister David Cameron and French President Nicolas Sarkozy Tuesday sign a deal for extensive cooperation which will include the creation of a joint rapid reaction force and a shared nuclear testing facility. But many of Britain's more eurosceptic newspapers questioned whether France will prove a reliable partner.

"Seldom do important defence stories present opportunities for belly laughs," said the editorial in the middle-market Daily Express. "But the news that Britain and France are to pool their armed forces does. Oh, where to begin? In 1066 perhaps; all those endless wars against the froggies that went on for hundreds of years; St Joan; the Battle of Agincourt when we showed them what's what; Napoleon getting his comeuppance; D-Day?" In the Daily Mail, a former British Army officer, Tim Collins, recalled the history of animosity felt by British soldiers for the French. "Horatio Nelson famously instructed his officers that 'you must hate a Frenchman as you hate the devil.'"Collins wrote. "Well it seems now we are to be one with them -- at least militarily. I must admit I am sceptical."

But The Times's Ben Macintyre highlighted that, as well as suspicion, Britain and France also had a "parallel tradition of mutual admiration". This has increased in recent years as more and more French and Britons have visited and lived in each others' countries due to improved transport links and European Union ties. And Philip Stephens in the Financial Times described the deal as a "cordial entente to match the realities of power". "France can no longer hope to organise Europe against America. Britain cannot substitute a close bond with the US for collaboration on its own continent," he wrote. "The pity is that it has taken the reality of decline to persuade them of the obvious."
by Staff Writers
London (AFP) Nov 2, 2010
Britain and France have been forced into a new defence pact by financial pressures and the desire to remain global players, but historic tensions could still undermine the deal, analysts said.

Nearly 1,000 years after the first cross-Channel clash at the Battle of Hastings, the new agreement will see the NATO neighbours share aircraft carriers and nuclear testing facilities and create a joint military force.

"I would like to be optimistic about it but it's hard. There is a history of mistrust," Sheila Tremlett, an expert on Anglo-French relations at the Defence Studies Department of King's College London, told AFP.

"Britain gets in close contact with France when it has to, not when it wants to."

French President Nicolas Sarkozy hailed the deal signed at a summit in London Tuesday as "historic", and both he and British Prime Minister David Cameron vowed that their countries would work closely together.

Experts said the driving force behind the pact was to maintain the two nations' clout on the world stage in the aftermath of the financial crisis -- with Britain in particular trying to slash a massive deficit.

Commentators in Britain have dubbed the new deal the "Entente Frugale" -- a play on the famous Entente Cordiale in 1904 which brought an end to centuries of conflict between the two countries.

"Quite frankly, there's no money left," Robin Niblett, head of the respected think-tank Chatham House, told AFP.

Etienne de Durand, director of the Brussels-based IFRI (French Institute of International Relations) said recently it was a choice between "entente or oblivion" for Europe's only nuclear powers.

But Paris and London would therefore work hard to make a success of the landmark new agreement, analysts said.

"They will make it work because they have to," said Julian Lindley-French, a professor of defence studies at the Netherlands Defence Academy and special professor of strategic studies at the University of Leiden.

"It's strategic, it's pragmatic, it's visionary, it's good for the transatlantic relationship and it's good for European defence," he told AFP.

Britain and France cooperated extensively in the past century including the First and Second World Wars, the ill-fated Suez crisis in 1956 and Franco-British military operations in the Balkans in the 1990s.

But the devil of the new agreement would be in the details, said John Keiger, an expert on French foreign, defence and security policy at the University of Salford.

The two countries fell out badly over the US-led invasion of Iraq in 2003 and the new agreement could struggle if there are similar foreign policy differences in the future, he said.

"It could potentially cause difficulties if Britain and France are operating a carrier together and there is some political crisis that occurs, and one of the two parties isn't in favour of intervening and the other is," Keiger told the BBC.

There was also a lack of "deep-seated" intelligence sharing between the two countries of the kind that Britain currently has with the United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, he said.

This could create difficulties if, for example, the French wanted intelligence information that US officials had not cleared for sharing.

Michael Clarke, director of the Royal United Services Institute in London, said previous attempts at military and industrial cooperation between Britain and France "always seem to run out of steam."

"This time it might be different because they are desperate (about money)," he told the BBC. "They always work at a political level. They create some useful synergies."

British newspapers, however, did not hide their scepticism.

The right-leaning Daily Mail borrowed a quote from General Norman Schwarzkopf, commander of coalition forces in the 1991 Gulf War, who joked that "going to war without the French is like going duck shooting without an accordion."



Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
The Military Industrial Complex at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


MILPLEX
Saudis discuss buying tanks from Spain, no deal signed
Madrid (AFP) Nov 2, 2010
A senior Saudi Arabian official discussed buying Spain's Leopard 2E tanks here Tuesday but no deal was signed for a contract reportedly worth up to three billion euros, a Spanish government official said. Visiting Prince Khaled bin Sultan, the Saudi assistant defence minister, discussed the possible contract in a meeting with Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, the official told AFP ... read more







MILPLEX
Russian MPs cool on missile treaty after US vote: official

Moscow needs details on NATO shield: minister

Missile Defense Agency Selects Raytheon To Provide New Missile Defense Radar

Raytheon Advanced Airborne Optical Sensor Studied For Missile Defense

MILPLEX
Taiwan arrests double agent spying for China

Taiwan missile to target Chinese air bases, ports: report

South Korea favors short-range missiles

Aerojet Technology Flight Tested To Replace DPICM Submunitions

MILPLEX
Three US drone strikes kill 11 militants in Pakistan

Providing ISTAR Capability For UK Armed Forces

US drone strike kills five militants in Pakistan: officials

IAI Offers New Ultra Light MiniPOP Payload For UAVs

MILPLEX
Raytheon To Provide Improved Track Correlation And Fusion Capability

Lockheed Martin Adds Radio Frequency Management To Tactical Network Planning Capability

Testing For AEHF Satellite Services Completed

Sagem Prime Contractor For RIF-NG New-Gen Soldier Info Network

MILPLEX
LockMart Awarded High-Power Microwave Energy Weapon Contract

Advanced Full-Motion Video Management Tools For Defense And Intel Users

F-22 Raptor Performs Air Demo For First Time Over Dallas

F-22 Raptor 4168 Heads To Its New Home

MILPLEX
Franco-British defence deal 'clearly essential': press

Brazil to decide fighter jet tender soon: Lula

Britain, France sign vast military deals

Britain, France sign landmark defence pact

MILPLEX
Change riptide reverses to slam Obama

Tokyo under fire over 'spineless' diplomacy

Outside View: Britannia

Republicans set to challenge Obama on US foreign policy

MILPLEX
Boeing Installing Beam Control System On HEL Laser Demonstrator

Maritime Laser System Shows Higher Lethality At Longer Ranges

Northrop Grumman To Increase Efficiency For Next-Gen Military Laser Technology

Boeing Receives Task Order For Design Of Free Electron Laser Lab Demonstrator


The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement