. Military Space News .
Iraqs Militia Problem

People gather round a pool of blood after an car bomb explodes in Iraq. Photo courtesy of AFP.
by Anthony H. Cordesman
UPI Outside View Commentator
Washington (UPI) May 19, 2006
During April, the problem of Iraq's ethnic and sectarian militias has gained more and more attention. Some articles have claimed they have become as serious a problem as the insurgency, or an even more serious prelude to civil war.

There is no doubt that Iraq's ethnic and sectarian tensions have continued to grow since late 2004, and accelerated during 2005. The failure to form a government of any kind, more sectarian and ethnic violence in virtually every mixed area in Iraq, and a lack of local security in much of the country have all increased the risk of civil conflict.

No one can really quantify the number of force relocations, killings, kidnappings, extortions, and other acts that are pushing Iraqis apart. No one, however, doubts that thousands of Iraqis have died, and ethnic cleansing, mixed with crime and local feuds, have affected the lives of tens of thousands. The true total to date may be in the hundreds of thousands, and certainly is if Iraqis who have moved or fled from fear are included.

This cannot, however, be blamed simply on the militias. The dividing lines in Iraq are far more complex. Crime is a constant problem and a threat to security, and is often mixed with ties to sectarian groups or local political factions. If there are no local militias or security forces, there almost always are criminals. In many areas there are both, and sectarian and ethnic forces can extort while criminals can claim to serve an ethnic or sectarian cause.

The more mixed a neighborhood or area is, the more the lines are blurred. In general, the more homogeneous the area, the better organized local security forces are, although sometimes at the cost of more sectarian and ethnic "cleansing." In many such areas, however, it is not some party militia in the national sense that really is involved, but a local security force or element loyal to a local leader. In a number of areas, the police are also loyal to a given leader and there are no clear lines of demarcation. In others, the police simply do not act.

Crime is a constant problem in every troubled area, and this is much of urban and sometimes rural Iraq. Ordinary criminals, part-time criminals, and "gangs," are all a threat, and they can easily be part of the local security force, a militia, police, or ex-police with IDs and uniforms.

As was the case in the Balkans, so many young men are out of work that the term "criminal" or "gang member" doesn't mean much. "Crime" is often the key to income of any kind. The irony is that the security services, military, and police are often the only major new source of real jobs in such areas, other than the paid militias -- generally paid much lower, local security forces -- very low pay, security guards or protection forces -- often paid even less, and insurgency -- paid sometimes.

The end result is not a militia threat per se, but rather an increasingly blurred mix of all of the security elements in Iraq, of which the militias are only a part. The Iraqi forces are all plagued by desertions and AWOLs that can go into the militias, local security forces, crime and the insurgency. In addition to the actual use of militias, sects and ethnic factions make use of police and security services. The end result is a virtual "stew" of factional forces with different recruiting bases and cross-membership.

This is compounded by the real-world nature of today's militias. Today's militias are not the militias of 2003. The military, security services, and police all recruited extensively from the pre-invasion militias once they began to form in 2003, and have drawn on them ever since. Many of the best elements of the militias were blended into the Iraqi forces from the spring of 2004 onwards, although best does not mean loyalty to the nation versus sectarian or ethnic faction.

Anthony H. Cordesman holds the Arleigh A. Burke chair of Strategy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.

Source: United Press International

Related Links
-

US forces cannot withdraw yet from any Iraqi province: general
Washington (AFP) May 17, 2006
US and coalition forces cannot yet be withdrawn from even Iraq's most stable regions, despite progress made in building up Iraqi security forces, the US military chief said Wednesday.







  • China denies US spying allegations
  • Growth of China, India is a benefit not a threat: Australian PM
  • Bush administration to meet lawmakers to push Indian nuclear deal
  • China considering US offer to observe military exercises

  • Cool the rhetoric on Iran: Annan
  • Nothing new in US approach to NKorea, says Seoul
  • Pakistani PM discusses Iran nuclear programme with Kadhafi
  • Iranian nuclear bomb 'flying gas chamber': Israel's Peres

  • Russian Army Chief Warns Over Non-Nuclear ICBMs
  • Taiwan plans to produce supersonic anti-ship missiles: report
  • Ex-Israeli army chief warns of long-range Iran missiles
  • Restraint and not pressure stops ICBM test: India

  • Harper's Next Move On BMD
  • LM To Upgrade ICBM Reentry System Upgrade
  • Hamilton Sundstrand's Thrust Vector Actuation System Demonstrated In THAAD Test
  • Kremlin Voices Concern At US Conventional Missile Plans

  • British Aerospace Production Up Strongly In First Quarter
  • Face Of Outdoor Advertising Changes With New Airship Design
  • NASA Denies Talks With Japan On Supersonic Jet
  • Test Pilot Crossfield Killed In Private Plane Crash

  • Boeing ScanEagle Demonstrates New Maritime Capabilities
  • UK First For Royal Navy UAV Trials
  • BAE Proposes Skylynx UAV For Marine Corps Tier II Program
  • Global Hawk Completes Wet Runway Test

  • Iraq's Militia Problem
  • US forces cannot withdraw yet from any Iraqi province: general
  • UK And Australian Prime Ministers Both Knew There Were No WMDs
  • Two British soldiers killed by bomb in Iraq: defence ministry

  • DRS Tech Receives US Army Contract For Next-Gen Thermal Weapon Sights
  • General Dynamics Awarded Contract For Stryker-Related Contracts
  • Russian Army to get new weaponry in 2006
  • Armor Holdings Receives Award For Up-Armored HMMWVs

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement