Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Military Space News .




THE STANS
NATO's Afghan strategy in jeopardy: experts
by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Sept 19, 2012


Coalition leaders say otherwise, but experts warn that NATO's decision to limit joint operations with Afghan forces threatens the alliance's strategy to hand over power and withdraw by 2014.

Announced on Tuesday, the move marks a setback to the US-led strategy for containing an 11-year Taliban insurgency, as a phased withdrawal of Western troops hinges on training and advising Afghan forces to take their place.

The decision was taken in a powder keg environment as protests sweep the Muslim world, and after an uptick in insidious blue-on-green attacks that have seen 51 NATO personnel shot dead by their local colleagues so far this year.

"It's a serious challenge to the strategy," Stephen Biddle, a George Washington University professor specializing in Afghanistan, told AFP.

NATO aims to train 350,000 Afghan soldiers and police by the end of 2014 as it transfers all security responsibilities to President Hamid Karzai's local forces.

The alliance is gradually withdrawing the 112,600 troops remaining in its ISAF force. The Pentagon said last week that there are currently 77,000 US troops in Afghanistan.

Jeffrey Dressler, senior research analyst at the Institute for the Study of War, said the effect on NATO's drawdown strategy depends on how long the limitations on joint operations remain in place.

"It's a minor setback at this point, but the significance of it obviously will increase with the length of time that the order stands," Dressler said. "If it continues for months, then it's definitely going to have an impact."

Australian Brigadier-General Roger Noble, deputy to ISAF's operations' chief, admitted the recent string of green-on-blue attacks had been dispiriting.

"The problem with the insider attack is it strikes right at the heart of our resolve," he told Pentagon journalists from Kabul. "It's one thing to be killed in action by the insurgents. It's quite another to be shot in the back of the head at night by your friends."

Noble said the decision to scale back joint operations was "just normal military business and common sense," and insisted it would not derail the drawdown effort.

"The bottom line is that beneath the noise and turbulence of day-to-day operations and events, the campaign remains on track to achieve its objectives," he said.

President Barack Obama's administration is under pressure from some to rethink its strategy, with three leading senators asking for a "strategic pause" to troop withdrawals.

"We cannot afford to rush to failure in Afghanistan," Republicans John McCain and Lindsey Graham, and Independent Senator Joe Lieberman wrote in a letter.

"We believe those conditions are now worrisome enough to justify an immediate suspension of further US troop withdrawals at this time."

During a videoconference with Karzai on Wednesday, Obama focused partly on the unprecedented wave of attacks on NATO troops by local comrades. The White House said the president was committed to pursuing his drawdown timetable.

US Defense Secretary Leon Panetta, speaking in Beijing, said the attacks were worrisome but insisted they would not delay or derail plans to complete a withdrawal of troops by the end of 2014 as planned.

Only a quarter of the insider attacks are believed to be the result of Taliban infiltration, and Biddle feared they could just be the "visible tip of a much larger iceberg" that is the inability of Western and Afghan forces to work together.

"It's a lot easier to fix an infiltration problem than cultural incompatibility," he said. "I think it has serious consequences for the way forward in the war."

Sarah Chayes, a former adviser to the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, was more categorical.

"We already know that this strategy broadly doesn't work," said Chayes of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

"The problem is much broader. In my view, an army is only the arm of a government. If the government -- the head and the body -- is nonviable, what good is an arm?

"If the international community doesn't address either Afghan government corruption or the role of Pakistan, I see little chance for a positive resolution."

.


Related Links
News From Across The Stans






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








THE STANS
Bomb kills nine in Pakistan's Peshawar: officials
Peshawar, Pakistan (AFP) Sept 19, 2012
A bomb apparently targeting a Pakistan air force vehicle ripped through a van in the country's northwestern city of Peshawar on Wednesday, killing nine people, officials said. Glass, metal and pieces of human flesh littered the ground near a busy market on the city's Kohat road after the explosion, which investigators said was likely to have been detonated remotely. "At least nine people ... read more


THE STANS
US to station second X-band missile radar in Japan

Israel's Arrow-3 missile-killer nears test

Lockheed Martin Conducts Successful PAC-3 Missile Flight Test at White Sands Missile Range

Missile Defense Agency and US Air Force award Raytheon $125 million contract for early warning radar upgrade

THE STANS
India follows Pakistan with missile test

Pakistan test-fires nuclear-capable cruise missile

Taiwan takes delivery of first Thunderbolt

Raytheon successfully tests HARM upgrades

THE STANS
NASA Global Hawks Support Hurricane Missions From Both U.S. Coasts

UAV proliferation worries security experts

Pakistan readies production of UAVs

AeroVironment Receives $16.5 Million of Funding from U.S. Army for RQ-11B Raven

THE STANS
Hughes Awarded Custom SATCOM Solutions Contract by GSA

4 SOPS begins testing newest AEHF satellite

SES Government Solutions Awarded Custom Satellite Solutions Contract in the US

Boeing Chosen for US Government's COMSATCOM Services Acquisition Program

THE STANS
Robotic tuna is built by Homeland Security

AEL SistemasTo Supply Unmanned Turrets to the Brazilian Army

Northrop Grumman's SmartNode Pod Enhances U.S. Army HARC System in Network Demonstration

USAF Awards Lockheed Martin Sniper ATP Sustainment Contract

THE STANS
Israel's now one of top arms exporters

Retrial of Canadian-German arms dealer delayed

Australia's defense policies criticized

AgustaWestland signs South Korean partners

THE STANS
China leaders debate Bo trial, prison: analysts

Philippines says coup plotter in secret China talks

Anti-Japan protests ease off in China

US tilt to Asia not aimed against China: Panetta

THE STANS
Precision Motion Tracking - Thousands of Cells at a Time

Nanoengineers can print 3D microstructures in mere seconds

Improved nanoparticles deliver drugs into brain

Penn Researchers Make First All-optical Nanowire Switch




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement