. Military Space News .
US should not panic over Islamists in Pakistan: analysts

by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Nov 14, 2007
In a doomsday interpretation doing the rounds in Washington, the "Islamist barbarians are at the gates" of power in Islamabad and ready to capture Pakistan's nuclear arsenal.

That is far-fetched, according to experts here who argued that in the crisis sparked by President Pervez Musharraf's declaration of emergency rule, the United States should not be shunning Pakistani religious parties.

"It's very unlikely that the Islamists are going to swing to power in Islamabad and seize the nukes," said Joshua White, a scholar at the School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) of Johns Hopkins University.

"It is, however, likely that they will be influential on the margins of Pakistani politics," said White, who recently returned from a year in Pakistan's insurgency-torn North West Frontier Province.

He said the "vast, vast majority of Pakistanis you meet reject this kind of extremism, and I wish it was a message that got out a lot more."

On Tuesday, detained former premier Benazir Bhutto moved to forge an anti-Musharraf coalition including the Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal (MMA), an alliance of six Islamist parties.

MMA officials gave a positive gloss on Bhutto's initiative, as did her one-time rival Nawaz Sharif, raising the possibility of a unified opposition boycott of elections proposed by Musharraf for January 9.

The last time Pakistanis elected a parliament, in 2002, the MMA won about 11 percent of the vote. A pro-Musharraf group won the most seats in the ballot, which was effectively barred to the exiled Bhutto and Sharif.

The United States has called for "free and fair" elections this time round, insisting that Musharraf must first lift his state of emergency.

Where they have won power, such as in the northwest region, MMA members have proven "profoundly ordinary" as they get to grips with government rather than breathing fire in opposition, White said.

Musharraf meanwhile has angrily dismissed US fears that Pakistan's 50-odd nuclear weapons could fall into the wrong hands, as the Taliban and Al-Qaeda make inroads in areas bordering Afghanistan.

"When we think about the extremists, we're not talking about the political parties," Pakistan expert Marvin Weinbaum of Washington's Middle East Institute said at a SAIS seminar.

"And even when we talk about the extremists, many are heavily infiltrated by the security forces," he said, arguing that the MMA parties were as much threatened by still-more radical groups like the Taliban as mainstream forces.

"These parties have to be seen as part of the political firmament" and should not be "marginalized" by the United States, Weinbaum said.

Beyond the politicians, Pakistan's shadowy Inter-Services Intelligence, which is closely involved in the hunt for militants linked to Al-Qaeda, has long been viewed with suspicion for its past sponsorship of the Taliban.

And some scientists associated with the nuclear program are suspected of harboring extremist sentiments and could, it is feared, leak secrets to terrorists or anti-Western regimes such as Iran.

The reputation of Pakistan, the world's only known nuclear-armed Muslim country, has been tarnished by the sale of atomic secrets on a global black market headed by its disgraced chief nuclear scientist Abdul Qadeer Khan.

Washington Post columnist Charles Krauthammer, who wrote that the "barbarians are at the gates" last week, warned of the risks attached to Pakistan disintegrating into a failed state.

"The Taliban and its allies are gaining in strength and waiting to pick up the pieces from the civil war developing between the two most westernized, most modernizing elements of Pakistani society" -- the army and the middle-class elite, he wrote.

That is a fundamental misreading of the situation, according to White, who said that the Taliban's violence is hated even in insurgent hotbeds of Pakistan such as North and South Waziristan.

What does appeal to communities in the ill-developed, feudal region bordering Afghanistan is the prospect of clean government rooted in a religiously observant movement free of corruption, he said.

Christine Fair, senior political scientist at RAND Corp., noted that Pakistan is not alone in seeing a revival of religiously inspired political thinking.

Some 60 percent of US evangelicals favor a Biblical interpretation of American law, she cited polls as suggesting.

Such hardline Protestants were no more likely to erect "Christian Sharia in an American Jesus-stan" than Islamic extremists are to swamp Pakistan's federal government, she said.

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
News From Across The Stans



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


US military looks to supply lines amid Pakistan unrest
Washington (AFP) Nov 14, 2007
The US military has begun making contingency plans in case its supply lines to its forces in Afghanistan are disrupted by the turmoil in Pakistan, a Pentagon spokesman said Wednesday.







  • China pursuing aggressive spying program: US commission
  • US informs Nigeria of plan to set up military command in Africa
  • India committed to boosting ties with Russia
  • Russian parliament votes freeze on CFE treaty

  • IAEA sees progress but says Iran still enriching uranium
  • Iran arrests 'more nuclear spies'
  • US military leaders march to a softer beat on Iran
  • N. Korea 'making progress' on resolving outstanding nuclear issues: US

  • Raytheon Delivers 3000th Joint Standoff Weapon To The US Navy
  • Raytheon Standard Missile-3 Achieves Dual Intercepts In Space
  • Pakistan missile attack kills 10, militants parade troops
  • Analysis: Israel ups airline defenses

  • BMD Watch: Tauscher will block Euro-bases
  • Proposed missile defense upgrade for Taiwan announced
  • Missile Tit-For-Tat
  • Outside View: BMD base fears

  • Time Magazine Recognizes The X-48B
  • Virgin to offer carbon offsets alongside drinks and perfume
  • NASA sorry over air safety uproar
  • Airbus superjumbo makes first commercial flight

  • BAE Systems Wins Unique Approval For Unmanned Air Systems
  • Elbit Systems To Supply UAV Systems To The Israeli Defense Forces
  • Unmanned Air System Project For South Coast Formally Launched
  • SDS Awarded Contract By USAF To Enhance MQ-1 Predator Training System

  • Hidden outlays to push war costs to 3.5 trillion : Democrats
  • US military meets recruiting goals
  • Feature: Marines target smugglers
  • Poland's Iraq mission to end in 'current form': incoming PM

  • First Four M113 Armoured Personnel Carriers Accepted Into Service
  • Deadly Precision: Snipers Get New Longer Range Rifles
  • Thompson Files: Experts are right on F-22
  • F-35 - The Great Escape

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement